Friday, September 2, 2011

Reassessing Zone D

For many of us, Zone D was probably the first higher level tactic we were taught. It is an extremely common defensive strategy used from social league matches to World Championships. I think, however, that many people take for granted the use of Zone D, and assess it's success or failure based on flawed criteria.

We use different types of zone defense for many purposes. However, it is important to note that the goal of zone D is not to stop the other team scoring every single point (otherwise it would almost always be a failure - as would Man D, if it had the same goal). The initial goal is to force the opposition to change the way they score - in other words, to revert to Plan B.

Of course by forcing this change, we are hoping to make it more difficult for the opposition to score too - and we can make inferences about the likelihood of this based on variables such as the players on the opposition, the conditions, and the type of zone we are considering playing. The relative importance of these factors can change, too. For example, if the wind was blowing at 50 knots, it probably wouldn't matter too much which zone we played or who the opposition was. But if it was completely still, then these factors become more important.

So how should we assess the effectiveness of a zone? My answer is, we should ask whether by forcing the oppositions change to Plan B they are scoring in a way that is more desirable to us - or not. I'll finish with an example.
A team has been scoring downwind reliably against us from a small amount of passes and an early huck. This is a very unfavourable situation to us - there is only a very low chance of turnover on the early passes, and even when (if) the huck fails, we will be starting offense from very deep in the field, and have to work it back up into the wind. Should we keep persisting with our Man D?
I would argue that in this situation, putting a zone on is likely to increase our chances of success. To start with, having 4 people establishing a high pressure situation around the first couple of passes is going to be more likely to lead to more early turnovers. This in turn will make it less likely for a huck to be thrown (and even if it is, there are two deeps, so the reliability of it will be lower), with the opposition instead more likely to work it up through the zone. While they may (or may not) do this easily, I still find it favourable in the sense that there is a higher likelihood of turning it over due to the greater volume of passes. Of course, once the zone is broken the score may become relatively simple, and this would also be considered when assessing the zone's effectiveness. However I believe that rethinking our assessment process when it comes to Zone D is very important, as it can really impact upon the way we play Ultimate.

1 comment:

  1. Hey Steve, this is a very good synopsis of why were might change to, or persist with Zone D. That will ultimately come down to judgement of the captains, could you briefly outline how this understanding can help everyone else, and how they can use this information in their own game?

    ReplyDelete