Wednesday, August 24, 2011

A word about tactics

Hey everyone,

There has been considerable talk about the various plays/tactics/strategy/whatever-you-want-to-call-it that we will be using at the tournament. I just wanted to quickly say something more general about tactics.

Why We Use Tactics
Frisbee in its 'natural state' (ie a bunch of beginners running around essentially aimlessly) is extraordinarily chaotic. At a base level, we use strategy to attempt to control this chaos - to limit the many variables that may apply in any given situation. Using a vertical stack tries to control the game so as to give us plenty of space to throw into down the field. Using a force is an attempt to reduce this space. Higher level tactics relies on the same principle, but with an added consideration - that simple, base level strategy isn't sufficient when faced with higher-level offense. Thus, we introduce plays that seek in specific ways to exploit the weaknesses and minimise the strengths of various opposition tactics (both offensive and defensive), and to maximise our own strengths and minimise our own weaknesses. Through this process, we hope to create more opportunities for ourselves to score, to get D's, etc, etc.

Why do they work?
Essentially, because every player on the field has a better idea of what every previous, current, and [anticipated] future situation will mean to them (by 'situation' I mean ANY change in the game - whether it be a player movement, a disc movement, stall count change, foul call, etc etc). This means that players can be more proactive (rather than reactive) when it comes to their involvement in play. In the meantime, the other team will still be on the same reactive level as before, and this gives us an advantage. As an extension of this, it is likely that more opportunities will be created!

On Opportunities
So one of the ideas associated with the use of tactics is the creation of opportunities... Does this mean we must strictly adhere to strategy in the hope that our opportunities will come 'in all the right places'? The short answer is no. To qualify this answer is important though. The best way to do this is perhaps through an example:
Player A gets the disc on the sideline, as intended by the play that was called at the start of the point. The play says that they should wait for a handler to fake a cut up the line, then double back and get the disc running towards the middle of the field. As 'A' looks downfield, they see that Player B is open 10 metres away, also on the sideline. Should Player A throw the disc to Player B, or should they wait for the called option?
The things to consider in this scenario (or any other) are numerous. Will taking this opportunity shut down further opportunities? Is this opportunity higher or lower risk? Is this opportunity higher or lower reward? In the above scenario, I would probably decide that the benefit of getting a potential breakside pass out to a handler in power position would outweigh the benefit of a ten metre gain with the force, and would thus stick with the called play. However, I would reassess this if I was only 8 metres out from the endzone. The basic message? It ultimately comes down to you to decide, and this decision will depend on the various nuances of the given situation.

In summary: Tactics provide us with a way to maximise our strengths and minimise our weaknesses in relation to our opposition. They seek to create opportunities that we can utilise more effectively than those created out of pure chance. However, the final responsibility will always rest with you, the player with the disc in your hand, to assess a particular situation and make a decision as to what you do. You still have the power to take another opportunity, if it presents itself.
And guess what? If something doesn't come off, you'll still know basically what everyone else is doing!

Thanks for reading,
Steve


2 comments:

  1. Great post Steve :). As an example from our training game, we had called a vertical stack play in one point but due to a bad throw from the opposition I got the disc on the line about half way up the field.

    I could have waited fo pr a primary mid but I could see Elvin doing a fake in for an eventual long. As soon as I was sure the opportunity was on I hucked for a score :)

    So yeah, I totally agree with the overarching idea of using tactics t create opportunities, with the person with possession deciding which opportunity to take :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Excellent post Steve (you should write a book!)

    Another consideration of allowing the person with the disc some freedom to make decisions is that it adds another layer of complexity to defend against. For example if a team *always* waits for the set play and the defense know what that play is likely to be, then they can very closely predict what will happen and make adjustments to prevent it being successful.
    Taking opportunities as they present themselves makes life much harder for the defenders.

    Cheers, Charlie

    ReplyDelete